06/21/2026
"Resellers are the reason thrift stores are so expensive now."
I hear this all the time, but the reality is much more complicated.
Most resellers are not getting rich. The average reseller earns a modest income, and for many it's simply a side hustle used to pay bills, supplement retirement, stay home with children, or earn extra money in an economy where everything costs more.
What many people don't see is the work that happens after an item leaves the thrift store. Resellers spend hours sourcing, cleaning, repairing, researching, photographing, measuring, listing, packing, shipping, and handling customer service. That $5 item often represents an hour or more of labor before it's ever sold.
The truth is that thrift store prices have increased largely because thrift stores themselves have changed. Many major chains now research prices online, use automated pricing systems, and even pull valuable items from stores to sell on their own websites and auction platforms before shoppers ever see them on the sales floor.
Meanwhile, some of these nonprofit organizations pay their top executives salaries that reach hundreds of thousands of dollars per year, while customers are being charged near-retail prices for donated goods.
And let's talk about the claim that resellers "take all the good stuff from poor people."
Resellers don't create scarcity. Thrift stores receive enormous volumes of donations every dayโfar more than they can sell. In fact, many stores discard, recycle, or export excess inventory because they receive more donations than they can process.
Resellers also provide value by:
-Keeping usable items out of landfills
- Finding homes for niche, collectible, and vintage items
-Preserving pieces of history that might otherwise be thrown away
-Making unique items available to buyers who don't have access to local thrift stores
- Supporting a circular economy through reuse
At the end of the day, resellers are customers just like everyone else. They shop the same aisles, pay the same prices, and take on all the risk. Sometimes an item sells. Sometimes it sits for months. Sometimes they lose money.
If thrift stores are becoming too expensive, it's worth looking at the pricing decisions being made by the stores themselvesโnot just the people trying to make a little extra income from the things they buy.
What's your take? Have thrift store prices increased because of resellers, or because thrift stores realized they could charge more?