12/06/2025
My great-grandmother was a Potter. Now will research to see if this Potter family is part of my GG family.
The Thanksgiving the Baby Was Born in the Church, 1893
Cranberry, North Carolina, November 23, 1893
The preacher had just finished the Thanksgiving sermon when sixteen-year-old newlywed Lillie Potter doubled over in the third pew. Her water broke right there on the pine floor, three weeks early and faster than anyone expected.
The women cleared the men out, turned the altar into a birthing bed with quilts and the preacher’s own coat for a pillow, and sent the fastest boy running for Granny Wise, the midwife who lived two miles up the creek.
Granny never made it. The baby crowned before the boy was out of sight.
Lillie’s mama and three neighbor women took over. The only light was the coal-oil lamps and whatever sun came through the frosted windows. The only hot water was what they boiled in the church’s communion kettle.
While Lillie pushed, the men stood outside in the cold, hats in hand, praying loud enough to rattle the steeple. The preacher paced the porch quoting every Bible verse he knew about babies and deliverance.
At 2:17 p.m. a girl’s first cry rang out inside the little log church, clear and strong as a church bell. The men outside let out a cheer that scattered crows for half a mile.
They named her Grace Mercy Cranberry Church Potter (Grace for the day, Mercy for the safe passage, and the rest because that’s exactly where she decided to be born).
The women cleaned mother and child with the same basin they used for baptisms, wrapped the baby in the altar cloth, and carried her out to show the waiting fathers.
Preacher lifted her high and declared, “This child is already baptized in the Lord’s house. Reckon we’ll dedicate her proper next Sunday.”
They ate Thanksgiving supper on the church grounds that evening (turkey, dressing, and seventeen kinds of pie) while baby Grace slept in the same cradle that had held half the babies in the county for christening.
Every year after, on the fourth Thursday of November, the Cranberry Church bell rang exactly at 2:17 p.m. (no matter who was preaching) just to remind the mountains that once, in that very sanctuary, a Thanksgiving baby decided the world could wait a few more minutes, but love could not.
Grace grew up, married, married a preacher’s son, and when she died in 1981 at eighty-eight, they buried her in the churchyard under a stone that reads:
Born in the House of the Lord
Thanksgiving Day 1893
Returned Home the Same Way