04/23/2026
Can I be honest with you for a second?
Most people bake with their starter at the wrong time. Not because they are doing anything wrong — but because nobody ever showed them what "ready" actually looks like.
So here are the 5 signs I look for every single time before I bake.
The first one is that it doubled in size after feeding. Not once or twice — but reliably, every single feed, at roughly the same time. That consistency is what tells you the yeast colony is actually strong.
The second one is the dome. A healthy starter at its peak forms a beautiful dome on top. If the surface is flat or starting to pull away from the sides, it already peaked and you missed the window.
The third one is bubbles deep inside the jar — not just on the surface. When the whole mass looks airy and bubbly all the way through, the yeast is working everywhere, not just at the top.
The fourth one is the smell. Tangy, ye**ty, almost like fresh bread or mild yogurt. Never harsh, chemical or sharp. That pleasant smell tells you the fermentation is going in the right direction.
And the fifth — the one I rely on most — is the rise-and-pause test. After feeding, mark the level with a rubber band. When it stops climbing for 20 minutes in a row, it has peaked. That is your window. Use it immediately.
If you bake at that moment your bread will thank you for it.
As always, I hope this helps someone 🙏
Danica Recipes