Neumann's Hilltop Treasures

Directions

Neumann's Hilltop Treasures Come discover a unique shopping experience featuring locally owned treasures and four amazing local vendors.

From vintage finds and collectibles to home décor, gifts, and one-of-a-kind treasures, there's truly something for everyone!

Stop by the store, we are open early, check out the sale tables outside for some fabulous deals!
11/05/2026

Stop by the store, we are open early, check out the sale tables outside for some fabulous deals!

11/05/2026

REMEMBER WHEN?

We used to save butter tubs, coffee cans, bread bags, and just about EVERYTHING because it might come in handy someday!

What did your family save and reuse?

Let's hear it!

IT'S HERE! TREASURES ARE WAITING! We've been busy adding new treasures, and there's plenty to come check out!** Christma...
11/04/2026

IT'S HERE! TREASURES ARE WAITING!

We've been busy adding new treasures, and there's plenty to come check out!

** Christmas decor
** Gift items
** Clothing
** Home decor
** Vintage finds and so much more!

We also have new vendors, Jamie has has beautiful decor in our display case, Melissa has some amazing vintage Christmas decor in our bookcase and Four Corners Farms has a lot of healthy living items straight from their farm!

Doors open at NOON today!

We've been working hard getting everything ready, but please be patient with us as some items still need priced. Don't be shy about asking Martha for a price — she'll be happy to help! ❤️

Grab your shopping buddy and come see what's new at Neumann's Hilltop Treasures!

You never know what you'll find! 🛍️

11/03/2026

🎄🛍️ **Grab your shopping buddy, bring your wallet, and get ready to SHOP!** 🛍️🎄

We open at **NOON TOMORROW!**

We've been working hard the last couple of days getting the store ready for you! Lots of new and vintage Christmas treasures, home decor, books, and SO MUCH MORE have been added! 🎁

**BIG NEWS FOR THURSDAYS!**

Stop by and see Marilyn at **10 AM Thursday!** That's right, we're now opening at **10 AM on Thursdays**, and we'll even have a sale table or two outside for you to shop!

Come see what's new at **Neumann's Hilltop Treasures!** You never know what you'll find! ❤️

📣 Grab a friend and help us spread the word!

11/03/2026

You've got $20 to spend at Neumann's Hilltop Treasures.

Are you shopping for:

🏠 Home décor
🎁 Gifts
🕰️ Vintage goodies
🔧 Tools
🤩 Whatever catches your eye!

Tell us your shopping style

Thanks for being a top engager and making it on to our weekly engagement list! 🎉 Tammi Krieg, Leslie Austin, Kaleb Wedde...
11/03/2026

Thanks for being a top engager and making it on to our weekly engagement list! 🎉 Tammi Krieg, Leslie Austin, Kaleb Weddell, Kimberly Workman Burney

11/02/2026

🎄 New treasures are arriving at Hilltop Treasures! 🎄

All of our booths are getting a fresh look with new treasures, unique finds, and LOTS of Christmas decor!

Our vendors have been busy restocking and rearranging, so there's plenty of new stuff to check out!

And we have some exciting additions coming this week!

🎄 Angela with Four Corner Farms is joining us!

🎅 Melissa is bringing in vintage Christmas treasures!

✨ Jamie is bringing beautiful treasures to add to our display case!

There's going to be plenty of new things to see, so stop in, take a look around, and see what catches your eye. You never know what you'll find!

Neumann’s Hilltop Treasures
1221 S Bloomington St, Greencastle, IN

🕒 Store Hours:

- Sunday – Tuesday: CLOSED
- Wednesday 12 - 6
- Thursday 10 - 6
- Friday: 12–6
- Saturday: 10–5

🎄 Shop small, shop local!

11/01/2026

🎵 SUNDAY SING-ALONG!

What song comes on the radio and instantly takes you back to your younger days?

Bonus points if you tell us the memory that goes with it! ❤️

Still haven't found the costume you want? Last minute invitation to a party? Want to get some great deals on next year's...
10/30/2026

Still haven't found the costume you want? Last minute invitation to a party? Want to get some great deals on next year's decorations?

Stop by and see Janet Torr Jayne today or Samara Alexander tomorrow, booth 1 all Halloween including decor, blow ups, costumes, we even have a wedding dress if Bride of Frankenstein sounds good and blowup costumes.

**1221 S Bloomington St, Greencastle **

Open 12 to 6 today and 10 to 5 tomorrow.

10/29/2026

😩 TREASURE HUNTER REGRETS!

What's something you passed up at a sale and STILL wish you had bought?

We've all had that ONE treasure that got away!

Tell us your story!

Address

1221 South Bloomington Street
Greencastle, IN
46135

Opening Hours

Wednesday 12pm - 6pm
Thursday 10am - 6pm
Friday 12pm - 6pm
Saturday 10am - 5pm

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Neumann's Hilltop Treasures posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Shortcuts

Share

Category

Nearby interior services

Other Antique Stores in Greencastle

Show All